thinkingvoter.com

Back to all races
Federal raceDistrict 5

Representative in Congress, District 5

Federal

Thinking for yourself matters

All races

Meet the candidates

Unbiased view on

John H. Rutherford

Currently represents District 5

Rachel Grage

3 candidates. Listed as they appear on the ballot.

John H. Rutherford

Rachel Grage

John H. Rutherford

Rachel Grage

William Lintag Upham

Position on major issues

John H. Rutherford is a politician currently serving as the U.S. Representative for Florida's 5th Congressional District. Before entering federal politics, Rutherford built a 41-year career in law enforcement with the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office, culminating in his election to three terms as the Sheriff of Duval County from 2003 to 2015. In Congress, he serves as a high-profile member of the House Committee on Appropriations.

Party is hidden. Tap a black bar to reveal.

Party:

Currently represents District 5

3 candidates. Listed as they appear on the ballot.

We share more ground than you might expect

Common Ground

Common Ground shows where candidates agree, no matter their party.

Thinking for yourself matters

Position on major issues

Position on major issues

Position on major issues

Abortion and reproductive policy

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Agriculture and rural policy

Official statement

FACT: The OBBBA is a lifeline to rural America. Read full quote

Official record

Voted Yes on Emergency Conservation Program Improvement Act of 2025

Jun 23, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

Cosponsored Florida Freeze Disaster Assistance Act of 2026

Jun 2, 2026 · Source: Congress.gov

+18 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Artificial intelligence

Official record

Cosponsored Foreign Adversary AI Risk Assessment and Diplomacy Act

Jan 21, 2026 · Source: Congress.gov

Voted Yes on AI for Main Street Act

Jan 20, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

Cosponsored Protecting Our Children in an AI World Act of 2025

Apr 29, 2025 · Source: Congress.gov

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Civil rights and freedoms

No public positions found.

Criminal justice and policing

Official statement

As a former Sheriff with over 40 years of law enforcement experience, nothing is more important to me than the safety and security of our community. In Congress, I’m advocating for policies focused on keeping kids safe in school, families safe at home, and police safe while doing their important and dangerous job.

Official statement

Today, Congressman John Rutherford (FL-05) introduced H.R. 6955, the Investing in Uniformed Division Leadership Act, with Bennie G. Thompson, Ranking Member of the House Committee on Homeland Security.

Official statement

Representatives John Rutherford (FL-05) and Josh Gottheimer (NJ-05) reintroduced the Invest to Protect Act, along with Representatives Anthony D’Esposito (NY-04) and Steven Horsford (NV-04). Read full quote

+160 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Economy, jobs and wages

Removing government red tape to reduce costs and allow small businesses to thrive

Official statement

FACT: Workers across the country will see real wage growth. Raises real wages for American workers by as much as $7,200, helping families keep more of what they earn Helps grow paychecks faster than inflation, so you can buy more with the same amount of money

Promoting commonsense legislation to help cut grocery, gas, and electric costs

+185 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Education

Official statement

On Tuesday, U.S. Congressmen John H. Rutherford (R-FL-05) and Joe Neguse (D-CO-02) introduced H.R. Read full quote

Official statement

This week, Congressman John Rutherford (FL-05) introduced H.R. Read full quote

Official statement

As a former Sheriff with over 40 years of law enforcement experience, nothing is more important to me than the safety and security of our community. In Congress, I am focused on keeping kids safe in school, families safe at home, and police safe while they are on the job.

+53 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Elections and voting

Increase transparency in campaign finance, reduce the influence of big money in politics, and hold public officials to the same standards expected of every citizen.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Energy

Promoting commonsense legislation to help cut grocery, gas, and electric costs

Supported protecting our coastal waters and banning oil drilling off the coast of Florida

Worked to protect our beaches, ocean, and waterways from offshore drilling

+62 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Environment and climate

Official statement

Florida’s environment is central to our state’s economy and Florida way of life. I take seriously the responsibility to be a good steward of our environment, so that it can be there for generations to come. That is why I have worked to protect our environment through prudent regulation that prevents unnecessary harm.

Supported protecting our coastal waters and banning oil drilling off the coast of Florida

Worked to protect our beaches, ocean, and waterways from offshore drilling

+112 more

Defend coastal ecosystems, expand conservation funding, and invest in disaster resilience.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Families and social services

Official statement

Includes common sense community engagement requirements for able-bodied adults aged 19–64, which can be waived by states on a case-by-case basis for temporary hardships like hospitalizations or disasters Protects the most vulnerable, including children, seniors, those with serious mental or physical disabilities, pregnant women, caregivers, and those already complying with Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) or Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) work rules Gives states control over work and community engagement requirements, providing $200 million to help implement the new requirements Roots out waste, fraud, and abuse by removing the deceased from enrollment rolls, verifying beneficiary addresses, and making sure only eligible Americans receive benefits FACT: The OBBBA protects vital programs like SNAP for Americans and rewards states for making proper payments. Read full quote

Official record

Voted Yes on Removing Barriers to Work for Disabled Americans Act

Jul 23, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

Voted Yes on Stop Child Care Scams Act of 2026

Jun 3, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

+21 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Firearms policy

Official statement

U.S. Congressmen John H. Rutherford (R-FL-05) and Jared Golden (D-ME-02) reintroduced H.R. 1773, the Federal Firearms Licensee (FFL) Protection Act, to increase penalties for robbing or burglarizing Federal Firearm Licensee (FFL) dealers. They were joined by 42 additional cosponsors in the House.

Official statement

I have compiled the following list of legislative actions I’ve taken in this regard: Sponsored the bipartisan Protect and Serve Act to increase penalties for ambush-style attacks on law enforcement officers. Read full quote

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Government reform

Official record

Voted Yes on LACA

Aug 31, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

Voted Yes on Putting Patients First by Strengthening Provider Accountability in FECA Act

Jul 20, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

+28 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Healthcare

Fought for lower treatment and premium costs across the board

Fought for dependents to stay on parents’ insurance until age 26

Lower prescription drug costs for everyone

+183 more

In Congress, she will put her expertise in the healthcare field to work fighting for lower insurance costs and expanded access and coverage.

Work to keep healthcare premiums and prescription costs affordable, maintain federal cost-sharing supports, and stabilize home insurance.

Protect personal privacy and access to healthcare, ensure equality under the law for all Americans, and uphold dignity and due process in immigration policy.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Housing

Official statement

Today, Congressman John Rutherford (FL-05) joined Congresswoman Bonnie Watson Coleman (NJ-12) to reintroduce the Public Housing Fire Safety Act. Read full quote

Official statement

WASHINGTON, D.C. - Today, Representatives John Rutherford (FL-05) and Bonnie Watson Coleman (NJ-12) reintroduced H.R. 3170, the Homes for Every Local Protector, Educator, and Responder (HELPER) Act.

Official record

Voted Yes on Whistleblower Protection Act of 2025

Sep 15, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

+11 more

Work to keep healthcare premiums and prescription costs affordable, maintain federal cost-sharing supports, and stabilize home insurance.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Immigration

Official statement

The United States has been and will continue to be a nation of immigrants that welcomes people from around the world who love this land. However, to ensure our immigration programs are fair and effective, the U.S. government must uphold its own laws and prioritize the protection of our citizens.

Voted to fund building President Trump’s border wall, secure our borders and enforce our immigration laws

Official statement

Provides over $170 billion in multi-year funding to agencies like U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), and the Department of Justice (DOJ) to increase manpower, build infrastructure, and deploy modern technology to keep our homeland safe Includes $46.5 billion for wall construction, access roads, and sensors, plus another $6.2 billion for surveillance, vetting, and inspection equipment to prevent illegal crossings before they happen Provides $4.1 billion to hire and train new Border Patrol agents, air and marine officers, and CBP support staff – closing enforcement gaps and increasing operational strength at the southern border Designates $45 billion to expand detention centers and $30 billion for ICE to hire agents, upgrade facilities, and carry out lawful enforcement – including expanded 287(g) cooperation agreements with local law enforcement Reimburses local law enforcement agencies who shouldered the brunt of the Biden border crisis, empowering them to assist in federal efforts without draining local resource by creating two new grant programs, the State Border Security Reinforcement Fund and the BIDEN Reimbursement Fund Invests $3.3 billion into hiring immigration judges and prosecutors to address the backlog in our immigration courts Gives agencies flexibility to plan and execute missions without disruptions by providing funding through Fiscal Year 2029

+63 more

Ensure America's borders are secure through smart, efficient enforcement, while maintaining a fair and humane immigration system that respects due process.

Protect personal privacy and access to healthcare, ensure equality under the law for all Americans, and uphold dignity and due process in immigration policy.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Infrastructure and transportation

Fought for funding to rebuild our communities in the wake of deadly hurricanes

Creating Jobs Voted to support President Trump’s tax cuts for families and small businesses, putting more money in your pocket and creating more jobs in our communities Supported hundreds of millions of dollars of our tax money coming back to Northeast Florida to fund transportation and logistics projects that support tens of thousands of jobs

Official record

Voted Yes on Water Resources Development Act of 2026

Sep 16, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

+36 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Local control

No public positions found.

National security and foreign policy

Increase troop pay and give them greater resources to protect us at home and abroad

Official statement

FACT: The bill is expected to protect or create up to 7.2 million jobs, including 1.4 million new manufacturing positions, AND supercharge the U.S. economy by boosting the average annual growth by 1.2% annually. Read full quote

Official record

Cosponsored TAP Promotion Act

Oct 1, 2026 · Source: Congress.gov

+200 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Social Security and retirement

Supported President Trump’s efforts to lower prescription drug prices for seniors

Official statement

Offers additional childcare savings options and gives families more tools and freedom to plan for their futures Eliminates federal taxes on certain car loan interest for working families Allows parents to keep more of their paycheck by making the Child Tax Credit permanent, increasing it to $2,500 per child, and indexing it to inflation Provides greater access to the Adoption Tax Credit and the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit Expands access to the Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA) and Health Savings Accounts (HSA), which gives families the ability to use their pre-taxed dollars to better manage health care and childcare costs Gives parents the opportunity to take control of their children’s education by creating a federal tax credit for education scholarships Provides Social Security tax relief for senior citizens, allowing retirees to keep more of their earned benefits Streamlines student loan repayment options, making it easier for borrowers to pay off their student debt, while also saving taxpayers billions of dollars through reforms to student aid programs

Safeguard earned benefits and ensure long-term solvency for seniors and future generations.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Taxes and government spending

Official statement

The One Big Beautiful Bill will give Americans a much-needed tax break AND refocus our country on delivering for the American people. That’s why I voted YES.

Fighting inflation by blocking new taxes and slashing existing taxes

Official statement

MYTH: The One Big Beautiful Bill Act is just a tax break for billionaires. Read full quote

+134 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Technology and privacy

Official record

Voted Yes on Sunshine Protection Act of 2025

Jul 14, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

Voted Yes on Lulu’s Law

May 20, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

Voted Yes on Kari's Law Reporting Act

Apr 21, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

+36 more

Protect personal privacy and access to healthcare, ensure equality under the law for all Americans, and uphold dignity and due process in immigration policy.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Veterans

Voted to reform the VA and hold its employees accountable for the way they treat our heroes

Increase troop pay and give them greater resources to protect us at home and abroad Supported increased funding for mental health initiatives and efforts to combat PTSD in our veteran community Led the effort to provide grant money for programs that help veterans transition from active duty service to civilian life (H.R. Read full quote

Official record

Cosponsored Mammography Access for Veterans Act of 2025

Oct 1, 2026 · Source: Congress.gov

+56 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Animals and wildlife

No public positions found.

Emergency management

Official record

Voted Yes on Weatherizing Infrastructure in the North and Terrorism Emergency Readiness Act of 2025

Jul 13, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

Voted Yes on TRUE Accountability Act

Jun 8, 2026 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

Did not vote on Enhancing Stakeholder Support and Outreach for Preparedness Grants Act

Nov 19, 2025 · Passed · Source: House Clerk

+15 more

No public position found.

No public position found.

No public positions found.

Coverage differs between candidates because it depends on what each candidate has published. A short list does not mean a candidate has no views.

Corrections address not set yet.

What is unbiased view?

We hide parties by default so you can compare every candidate with an open mind, and maybe find common ground where you least expected it. Reveal them any time with one tap.

Thinking for yourself means looking past the labels to the ideas and values underneath.

Your saved picks are from a different ZIP. Start fresh?